Tuesday, 19 May 2015

Is Warhammer Vegan?

I had never considered the impact of the wargaming hobby on animals, so I thought I’d look in to it.

Tau enjoying a tofu & bean burrito (via http://destraudo.deviantart.com)

The two obvious places to start are paints and brushes.

In paints, ingredients from fish, bugs and cows can sneak in, like sepia ink, cochineal, ox gall, gelatin, shellac and bone char. There’s a few different brands of paints in my collection, and I asked the manufacturers about whether they contained animal ingredients.

Mike from Coat D'arms was the first to reply. He confirmed that all their ingredients are synthetic, and mentioned that they’d been asked several times before. It is nice to know that I’m not the only one who cares!

Alex Vallejo from Acrylicos Vallejo said that they had a company policy to avoid using animal ingredients when possible, but they do have a couple items in their Fine Arts and Acrylic Artists Colour ranges that use shellac and bone char due to the lack of synthetic substitutes. Fortunately, their model paints were free from squished bugs and burnt cow bones.

Alex also pointed out their policy on REACH, the EU regulation that is requiring every chemical to undergo safety tests. Valajeo has consulted with their major chemical suppliers and with only a few very rare exceptions, all the REACH tests on the ingredients they buy are done on dead tissue only.

Amy, who makes the MSP paints for Reaper Mini, said that she has never seen any animal-derived products in their bases or pigments. She also confirmed that, for Reaper’s models, the companies they work with use plastic resins, minerals, and inorganic chemicals only.

PrivateerPress said that all their Formula P3 paints are not tested animals and do not contain animal products.

Citadel was the only range that I didn't get a straight answer for. Games Workshop customer service said if I send them a list of the paints I want to use, they’d let me know if they contain animal products. It struck me as weird as this seems to be a question that these companies do get asked a lot, so I would have hoped that a company as big as Games Workshop would have answers ready. I didn't want to waste too much of their time listing off every paint in the range for an individual answer, so I just left it at that.

So far, things look really positive for anyone wanting to use paints without harming animals. But brushes are a bit of an issue.

On the side of fine hobby brushes, you’ll probably see that it is marked as “red sable”. Red sable fur comes from Siberian weasels, an animal that lives in Russia and China. I couldn’t find many sources on how these hairs are obtained. I emailed brush companies and even the fur industry’s press office. No answers. animalethics.org.uk was the only source of more information I could find. 

Apparently, these weasels are caught in leghold traps or snares, and the pelts are sold to the brushmakers who pluck and sort the hairs. For me, this is particularly worrying. Fur is nasty and I know I’m not alone in thinking so. An RSPCA survey in 2011 showed that 95% of British people would not wear real fur. And leghold traps are so cruel they were banned in England & Wales in the 1950s for being “too inhumane”. If something was so bad it was considered inhumane 60 years ago, you know it must be terrible. Further to that, Russia and China have minimal animal protection laws. In countries like Canada or Denmark, in theory, animals should not be left in traps for more than a day (they end up trying to chew their own leg off or dying in some other grisly way). China or Russia don’t have similar animal welfare standards.

It is bleak.

So, the solution: Are there any synthetic brushes that are up to the same standards? I’d love to hear thoughts on how well synthetic brushes hold up.

For my personal ethics, I’ll keep using my current set brushes for now. According to the Vegan Society, "Veganism is a way of living that seeks to exclude, as far as possible and practicable, all forms of exploitation of, and cruelty to, animals..." The words “as far as possible and practicable” stand out for me there. I don’t think compassionate people should opt out of the real world and move to a hippy commune or something. I think it is important to play an active role in non-vegan communities to demonstrate just how easy it is to live a cruelty-free lifestyle. So, for now, that means continuing to paint with fur brushes until I find a decent alternative, and I’ll also continue to advocate for animals by bringing delicious vegan snacks to game nights to impress friends.

From a bigger perspective, it would be great to ask companies to look in to their sourcing properly. Being the biggest name in wargaming, I’d love to know if Games Workshop knows where its fur comes from. And for them to adopt an official policy on trying to avoid animal products, like Vallejo has. And to know if the company has a stance on animal testing, including the compulsory REACH testing. If any animal-friendly Games Workshop shareholders are reading this, perhaps this is something you could help with.

6 comments:

  1. It's good to see someone else in the community concerned about something like this. I'm a pretty new vegan convert, and it just hit me this morning that paints might not be vegan. I found out not too long ago that glue isn't vegan either, but I haven't done the same level of research that you've done. There are sure to be vegan alternatives.

    Anyway, it was a huge relief reading your post, especially at how the big names mostly don't use animal products (well, apart from GW maybe, but I'll just buy vallejo).

    And if you want to try some high quality synthetics, try these guys: http://www.rosemaryandco.com/acrylic-brushes/golden-synthetic-acrylic

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Dan

    Just bumped on this. Thank you very much for your investigation on paints, very useful and interesting.

    Concerning paint brushes, i've tested a lot of synthetic brushes durig 2015 and i must say most of the mare disapointing. Sometimes they are just not precise enough, but most of time the problem is that their pointing end is curving very quickly.

    Yet, each time i complain about how annoying it can be, having studied a bit the animals used to make theses brushes, i never regret to stop buying their fur. These little beast do not deserve to be tortured just to save us money by not having to buy brushes too often.

    But it is indeed a problem since nobody seems to be making really high quality synthetic brushes.

    Of my investigations, at this time the best synthetic brushes i've found are:
    1. http://www.raphael.fr/Kaerell-acryl-869_fiche_42.html
    precise, and hold not too bad, or become useless not too fast. Size 4 is good for miniatures, equal too 0 in other ranges. i paint details likes eyes with it (you can check my blog here: http://unpaintedminis.canalblog.com/)

    2.http://www.dickblick.com/products/silver-brush-ruby-satin-synthetic-brushes/
    not bad either but tend too curve extremely fast

    3. Prince August synthetic brushes.
    I used to only paint with those but it felt like the quality decreased about one year ago. I may have been unlucky. I particularly liked the "longue de chat" which has a great shape to paint basecoats.

    Hope it will help you give synthetic brushes a go. i won't lie it is not as comfortable as high quality natural hair, but you won't become a bad painter because of them, and it feels really good when you watch weasels holding hands while asleep ;)

    I'm giving a go at the brushes mentionned aboe by Trumpkin right away thoug! Just ordered several of them

    ReplyDelete
  3. I am very happy to read this article! I have been a vegan for about 3 months now... And every day I realize that SOMETHING ELSE that I have in my house was made from/ tested on animals! From shoes, to bleach, to down pillows. Then I sat down and my hobby desk and said "But what about 40k?!?!?!"

    ReplyDelete
  4. As a long term vegan this was a great article when researching. I'm with you, I dont just chuck stuff away so I have several sable brushes that I will use right down the nib but I'm glad there are alternatives and will replace them as I go. I did the same research for paints and was happy about vallejo. Thanks for the article I will be continuing to expand the search into other supplies, plastic glues, green stuff and the like

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hey, I just read this post, great job! I'm a vegetarian myself and I'm not willing to use sable brushes, but I never really considered pigments. I'm glad to hear the odds are low that any animal derived ingredients are in my paints :). There are also adhesives to consider but I use PVA, cyanoacrylate, and epoxies, all of which are synthetic.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thank you for this article. Made me feel better, i did not think about the brushes when starting the hobby :/ mistake on my part. Thank you again :)

    ReplyDelete